The 2024 NFL preseason has offered an intriguing first look at some of the league's most promising first-round rookies. The performances of these rookies have been a mixed bag, showcasing moments of brilliance as well as areas needing improvement.
Quarterback Spotlight: Varied Performances
Caleb Williams, a highly anticipated first-round pick, had a somewhat lukewarm preseason debut. Completing just 50% of his throws, Williams averaged 8.5 yards per attempt over 42 snaps, showing glimpses of his potential but also areas requiring fine-tuning.
Jayden Daniels, on the other hand, appeared more comfortable under center. The rookie completed 12 of his 15 attempts for 123 yards, although he did not throw for any touchdowns or interceptions. His accuracy and decision-making are early indicators of a potentially successful transition to the professional ranks.
Drake Maye showcased a steady improvement through the preseason. He threw for 66 yards on 8 of 14 passing in the first two games but turned up the heat in the finale against the Commanders, completing 13 of 20 passes for 126 yards and a touchdown. This upward trajectory bodes well for his regular season prospects.
Meanwhile, Michael Penix Jr. and Bo Nix mirrored each other’s stats, with both quarterbacks completing 9 of 16 passes for 104 yards. Each has displayed a solid foundation that could be built upon as they gain more experience.
Receivers Make Their Mark
The rookie receivers have also made noteworthy impressions. Malik Nabers was a standout, making four catches for 54 yards in his second preseason game. His performance signals a potentially impactful season ahead.
Rome Odunze had a memorable moment with a long catch, recording one reception for 45 yards, while Brian Thomas Jr. spread his impact across the preseason with three catches totaling 93 yards. Each demonstrated the capability of becoming reliable targets for their quarterbacks.
Xavier Worthy added to the excitement by scoring a touchdown, albeit marred by a fumble. His dynamic play highlights both the potential and the occasional peril that comes with integrating new talent into the lineup.
Offensive Line: A Mixed Bag
Joe Alt and Olu Fashanu stood out among the rookie offensive linemen. Alt showed significant improvement in pass protection during his second preseason game, a vital development for his team's offensive schemes. In contrast, Fashanu allowed pressure on his first professional pass-pro set but later demonstrated his effectiveness in run blocking.
J.C. Latham impressed with his balance and power in the run game and displayed suddenness in pass protection, suggesting he could become a key player in the offensive line. Graham Barton also showed effective run blocking, adding depth to his team's offensive front.
Tyler Guyton's positive signs on special teams across two preseason matchups add another layer to his value, emphasizing versatility - a crucial trait for any rookie looking to secure a spot on the roster.
Defensive Disruptors
Defensively, Laiatu Latu made his presence felt with a sack in 13 pass-rushing snaps during Indianapolis's third game. Byron Murphy and Dallas Turner each generated two pressures on 20 pass-rushing snaps, showcasing an ability to disrupt opposing quarterbacks effectively.
However, not all rookies had a smooth ride. Chop Robinson, for instance, recorded no pressures across two games, indicating a need for adjustment and improvement as the season progresses.
Secondary Standouts
In the secondary, Quinyon Mitchell and Nate Wiggins were standouts. Mitchell allowed only two catches for eight yards, demonstrating impressive coverage skills. Wiggins recorded three pass breakups in one drive and allowed no receptions on two targets in the final game, highlighting his ability to be a lockdown defender.
Final Impressions
As the league pivots from the preseason to regular-season action, these first-round rookies will be players to watch. Each has shown flashes of the talent that made them highly touted in the draft, and their development will be a storyline to follow as the season unfolds. With foundational skills on display and areas for growth identified, the stage is set for what promises to be an exciting rookie campaign.